Meeting Minutes, 28 January 2025
Meeting of Merchant City and Trongate Community Council held in Glasgow City Chambers on 28 January 2025
Attended by: Tam Coyle (Chair), Community Councillors Gary Atkinson, Alice Cowan, David Cowan, David Hughes, Niall McColl, Gordon Millar, Scott Thornton and Ros Wardley-Atkinson ; Associate Community Councillors Peter Hayman and Ross Naismith; Ward Councillors Angus Millar and Depute Lord Provost Christy Mearns; Police Sergeant Iain Cooper-Cairns, PCs Nathan Baxter and Gentian Rapi; RA, KB, RE, DF, GF, KL, CMcI, EMi, PP, TMcK
Apologies: Community Councillor Colin McKay, Ward Councillor Philip Braat, AMcD
By video link: GAl, EMa
MINUTES OF NOVEMBER MEETING
These had been published on the Community Council’s Website.,
Adoption proposed by Gordon Millar, seconded by David Hughes. Carried.
POLICE REPORT
PC Baxter said that from 1-28 January a total of 107 crimes had been reported of which 49 had been detected. These included theft (especially from retail premises), possession of controlled substances and road traffic offences.
Local ‘Days of Action’ against illegal e-bikes and scooters had been running regularly since December, resulting in the seizure of 19 e-bikes with 79 offences reported to the Procurator Fiscal. These deployments would continue into February. In response to a question he said E-bikes can be classified as motor vehicles if ridden on pavements.
He and PC Moore had been joined as beat officers in the MCTCC area by PCs Rapi and McLeod. Scott said the Community Council was pleased about the increase in beat officers and the successful crackdown on illegally modified e-bikes.
Gordon asked what happened to seized e-bikes. PC Baxter said policy set by the Scottish Government was due to be changed and these bikes might no longer be returned to the rider.
Tam reiterated MCTCC’s call for all food delivery riders to be identifiable by a numbered tabard or bag, in case of an accident.
In response to a question from Scott PC Baxter said riders whose machines were impounded had to pay a release fee to the recovery company, not to police or Glasgow City Council (GCC)
Priority deployment locations, determined as a result of police observation of trends and in response to community needs, had included the Ramshorn Graveyard and New/Old Wynds. Plain clothed officers supplemented uniformed police.
There would be a substantial police presence in connection with the next football match between Celtic and Rangers at Parkhead on 16 March.
Tam noted that he and the two Vice-chairs are due to meet MSP Kaukab Stewart on 11 March when anti-social behaviour by football fans would be on the agenda.
Gordon asked what police were doing about graffiti. PC Baxter said this was regarded as vandalism but he had no statistics for arrests.
RA reported observing an incident outside the Glassford Street post office in which a man was carrying a knife and the shop owner had reported previous such incidents. PC Baxter said he would contact the shop owner to discuss this. Anyone caught up in such an incident should call 999.
CMcI (Colin McInnes, Homeless Project Scotland) said his project had equipment which detected if knives or similar including razor blades were being carried. It operated a Zero Tolerance policy.
He contended that Ward Councillors and MCTCC had not been supportive of HPS’ initiative in creating a homeless shelter in Glassford Street.
Councillor Millar said Glasgow City Council’s consideration of HPS’ planning application was ongoing following the Scottish Government’s dismissal of its appeal against an Enforcement Notice. HPS had never contacted him.
Depute Lord Provost Mearns said HPS had not been the easiest organisation to deal with. She herself had been a volunteer at its soup kitchen. She supported the initiative but not the way HPS had gone about it.
Scott said MCTCC was very much concerned about the plight of the homeless and had worked with The Simon Community which had delivered a presentation at a public meeting. The main reason CMcI was attending the meeting was so he could issue statements to the media.
He asked CMcCi if he was a resident of the Merchant City and Trongate area since only such residents could speak at the Community Council’s meetings. CMcI said he was the owner of a business in the area. Tam said MCTCC is constituted as a residents’ forum, not a business one.
Tam said he had attended the opening of the Thistle project (Safe drugs consumption facility in Hunter Street) and had been impressed, However, what happened after the building was closed at 9 pm?
PC Baxter said he could be contacted for advice on any matter via the Chair or Secretary.
ELECTED MEMBERS’ REPORTS
Councillor Millar said new legislation allowing local authorities to ban pavement parking, double parking and on double yellow lines would come into effect tomorrow throughout the city centre and elsewhere in Glasgow where there was no ambiguity about whether exemptions would be required.
For the first two weeks offenders would be given a warning notice and after that fines would be imposed. GCC’s computer systems had been amended to deal with this. It was recruiting more parking attendants.
He said work would start on re-developing George Square in a couple of months. Before that an exhibition would be set up in a corner of the Square followed by a comprehensive surrounding hoarding summarising the project and the area’s history.
In answer to a question from Ross, he said a water feature remains part of the plan but this would depend on costs not being prohibitive. This would be one of the last implementation items. Lessons had been learned from problems encountered in Sauchiehall Street including those concerning contract management.
KL asked about the re-siting of the taxi rank from George Square because of its re-development. Angus said he would check the latest position.
He said he had been advised by Councillor Bolander that benches currently in George Square would be re-positioned elsewhere and she had suggested that two should be placed outside the Ramshorn graveyard.
Councillor Millar said Council officers and factors had met to arrange a tidy-up of messy bins around Virginia Street and a new bin hub might be installed.
In answer to a question from RA about bin collections around Brunswick Street Councillor Millar suggested she should take up the matter with Louise Stewart at GCC.
Councillor Millar would join Community Councillors on a Walkabout through the MCTCC area on 14 February (12 noon to 1.30) to assess problems and plan remediations. The other three Ward Councillors would also be invited.
Depute Lord Provost Mearns said early morning noise problems reported by neighbours of Pipeworks “gentlemen’s sauna” in Metropole Lane seemed to have eased.
She had been following up the status of the development of the Ingram Street car park which MCTCC has campaigned unsuccessfully to be turned into Merchant City’s first park.
Tam said he understood GCC had given the developer six months in which to provide measures to mitigate noise to potential neighbours. This would expire on 14 February.
David Hughes said Glasgow Life had installed air conditioning fans on the roof of City Halls without planning permission. Peter said this was a separate issue to previous objections, raised by MCTCC and others, that due to the ‘Agent of Change’ principle a music venue could be closed down because of complaints from neighbours. EMi said that furthermore no impact assessment had been carried out.
Depute Lord Provost Mearns said an enforcement notice had been served on developers (now in administration) who had left a building site on Dixon Street in an eyesore state for a year or so.
RA asked what GCC was doing about pigeons. Councillor Millar said the Council was limited as to what it could do legally and a cull was out of the question. Community Enforcement Officers could ask those feeding the pigeons not to do so and this could be considered a littering offence.
Scott said road signage at the Stockwell Street-Bridgegate-Clyde Street junction was confusing since it suggested East-bound vehicles should turn left into Stockwell Street whereas that led them into a bus lane. Drivers realising the error or simply wanting to jump the queue then had to move right towards other oncoming traffic to avoid entering a cycle lane. GCC officials had indicated they would change the signage but so far nothing had happened and the situation remained chaotic.
PLANNING ISSUES
David Hughes said the next meeting of the North West Area Partnership would be on 25 February when the Neighbourhood Infrastructure Fund would again be a prominent agenda item. He had been annoyed to receive the latest criteria which included an unexpected addition saying funding bids including ‘business as usual’ items such as road improvements would no longer be included. This affected some of the 73 projects proposed by MCTCC.
Ross, MCTCC Planning lead, said he would like to see more pedestrianisation in the upper part of Candleriggs. Scott said this could not be pedestrian only because patrons had to access the City Halls and Old Fruitmarket venues.
Ross said he had written to GCC about the inadequate design of the High Street Avenues project and hoped for Ward Councillors’ support. Councillor Millar agreed the design was not as vibrant as those for other Avenues projects and he would request an update. The High Street was relatively narrow and this imposed space restraints.
On 30 January Community Councillors would attend further presentations on the Custom Quay-Clyde Street Avenues project. it was important the two sections were aligned.
Ross said the ‘Trees for Streets’ scheme was not the answer to the Community Council’s demand for more trees in its area. A better solution was for MCTCC to buy the trees and get GCC to plant them. Scott noted that David Cowan was representing the Community Council at an online Postcode Lottery funding seminar on Friday.
Ross thought a children’s play area should be considered for vacant land at the junction of George and High Streets.
LOCAL PLACE PLAN (LPP)
David Hughes noted that MCTCC was preparing its own LPP which would govern use of land and buildings and feed into the new City Development Plan (CDP2) and National Planning Framework (NPF4). Community priorities would be taken into account in planning decisions.
It could also include over-arching statements e.g. “we believe there is a surfeit of student accommodation and there is a need for a community centre and doctor’s surgery”.
A useful reference for drafting the LPP was the Merchant City Regeneration Handbook which mentioned reducing traffic flow in the High Street.
He asked Ward Councillors what was the timeline/deadline for submission of an LPP. Tam said he thought it was the end of March.
LITTER PICK
The Community Council’s next Litter Pick will take place on Saturday 22 February from 10.30 am to 1 pm (meet outside the Ramshorn graveyard), organised by David Hughes. Volunteers were welcome and equipment would be provided.
Posters will be distributed. Impact Arts’ students may assist.
FRIENDS OF THE RAMSHORN GRAVEYARD (FORG)
David Hughes, FORG Chairman, will be briefing young people from Impact Arts who will produce artwork for a virtual tour prior to public tours starting in the Summer.
PUBLIC TOILETS
Scott said MCTCC had submitted its comments to GCC and the British Toilet Association as part of the City Council’s public consultation.
COMMUNICATIONS AND COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT
Scott said the sub-group meeting due on 21 January did not take place and he would try to arrange another one. A prime subject was creation of the Community Council’s new Website, a prime tool for communicating with local residents.
TREASURER’S REPORT
Gordon reported £,6,884.39 in the bank. MCCTC had received its administration grant of £607.95 from GCC. The Zoom licence of £155 was due.
NEXT MEETING: Tuesday 25 February, 6.30-8.30 pm in City Chambers
AGM Minutes, 26 November 2024
These minutes will be presented to our AGM in October 2025 for approval
Attended by:
Community Councillors Tam Coyle (Chair), Gary Atkinson, Alice Cowan, David Cowan, Peter Hayman, David Hughes, Niall McColl, Colin McKay, Gordon Millar, Scott Thornton, Ros Wardley-Atkinson
Associate Community Councillor Ross Naismith
Ward Councillor Angus Millar
GA, CD, MD, TD, RE, GF, AM, EM, GMcI, PP, JR
Apologies – Baillie Christy Mearns. Councillor Eva Bolander, Councillor Philip Braat, Alasdair McDougall (MSP Kaukab Stewart’s office)
- Minutes of Annual General Meeting held on 31 October 2023
These had been published on the Community Council’s Website.
Adoption proposed by Gary Atkinson, seconded by David Hughes. Carried.
- Chairperson’s Annual Report
Just a few words to reflect on the last 12 months.
Firstly, a few thank yous, to my fellow Community Councillors ,this Community Council simply could not operate without our hard working team with a special shout out to my vice chairs [Scott Thornton and Gary Atkinson] and the sterling work on our website by Niall McColl and David Hughes on the Ramshorn Graveyard project.
POLICE SCOTLAND
A thank you to Sean McFadden [who unfortunately will be leaving us at the end of the month] and colleagues for all their support and Inspector Jonny Watters for the quarterly meetings.
Our four councillors, [ Eva Bolander, Christy Mearns, Angus Millar and Philip Braat.] Our MSP Kaukab Stewart and new MP John Grady [Glasgow East] for all support and assistance this year. I should also mention our former Westminster representative Alison Thewliss when we were represented by the now defunct seat of Glasgow Central.
David Hughes for attending the Area Partnership (ably assisted by Gary Atkinson) and to Gary for attending the Licensing Forum.
GLASSFORD STREET HOMELESS PROJECT
On 14/12/23 Homeless Project Scotland opened premises on Glassford Street without obtaining any sort of planning permission, nearly one year later Glasgow City Council are giving them extension after extension rather than enforcing their own legislation. The matter is now in the hands of the Scottish Government and we await the announcement with interest.
BARS AND RESTAURANTS
Merchant City and Trongate is not immune to the tough economical climate and we have suffered the loss of some outstanding premises. However, equally, there have been some fantastic openings over the last 12 months.
PLANNING
The MCTCC continue to liaise with all developers that have proposals in our patch and we will keep the local Community informed at all times
RAMSHORN GRAVEYARD
Our sub committee [chaired by David Hughes] are working away to improve the Graveyard….again we will keep you updated at our monthly meetings.
WARD 10 JAG MEETINGS
Tam, Gary and Scott have all taken turns of representing the MCTCC at the Ward 10 JAG Meeting [The JAG comprising of reps from the seven CC`s [MCTCC,Townhead, Blythswood and Broomielaw, Garnethill,Anderston, Yorkhill and Kelvingrove, Cowcaddens] to discuss areas of joint concerns
COMMUNITY LITTER PICK
The MCTCC have organised a couple of successful litter picks on Saturday mornings and we will continue to do so in 2025. We have noted recently that a couple of litter bins have been kept permantley on the street and we will work with GCC to get them removed asap.
There are still a number of long standing issues [pigeons/seagulls, Trees for Streets etc) but while all Community Councillors continue to share the workload I am confident that we can continue to go from strength to strength in 2025
Finally, we urge all members of the Community to attend our monthly meetings [the last Tuesday of the month in the City Chambers) and log on to our excellent website to be kept informed of all issues.
- Treasurer’s Submission of Independently Examined Statement of Accounts.
Gordon Millar reported a cash balance last financial year of £10,717. This year income totalled £1,530 with expenditure of £5,674 resulting in a deficit of £4,144. The balance at the end of MCTCC’s financial year (31 August) was £6,573.
Main expenditure was donations from the Community Council’s Grant Giving Scheme including a total of £2,308 to Friends of the Ramshorn Graveyard and Impact Arts plus an upgrade to the Website costing £1,590 with a similar sum due during the current financial year. Investment in the Website is regarded as an asset in accounting terms.
It had been a year of investment which also included purchase of a new meeting speaker and equipment for litter picks.
Unlike in previous years there had been no donations from film companies in the period under review. The Community Council was likely to be spending more than it received and was looking for grant opportunities.
Scott thanked Gordon for his first year as Treasurer which had helped greatly to get MCTCC’s finances into shape.
- Demit of Office Bearers
The following stepped down:
Chair – Tam Coyle
Vice-Chairs – Gary Atkinson and Scott Thornton
Secretary – Scott Thornton
Treasurer – Gordon Millar
Planning Lead – Peter Hayman
Licensing Lead – Gary Atkinson (Representative on Licensing Forum)
Area Partnership Lead – David Hughes
- Nominations for the election of Office Bearers and representatives:
- Chairperson
Tam Coyle
Proposed by David Hughes
Seconded by Niall McColl
- Vice-Chairpersons
- Gary Atkinson
Proposed by Scott Thornton
Seconded by Tam Coyle
- Scott Thornton
Proposed by Niall McColl
Seconded by Tam Coyle
Secretary
Scott Thornton
Proposed by David Hughes
Seconded by Peter Hayman
Treasurer
Gordon Millar
Proposed by Scott Thornton
Seconded by Alice Cowan
Planning Lead
Ross Naismith
Proposed by Scott Thornton
Seconded by David Cowan
Scott said Ross had done incredibly powerful work on planning issues since joining as an Associate Community Councillor, ably assisted by Peter who had done so for many years. The year had been a particularly busy one for planning applications in MCTCC’s area.
Peter deserved an enormous debt of gratitude for his work for the community going back decades.
Peter told the meeting he was stepping down from Community Council membership but would remain as an Associate.
- Licensing Lead
Gary Atkinson
Proposed by Tam Coyle
Seconded by Niall McColl
Tam will continue to forward to Community Councillors Licensing applications submitted to Glasgow City Council.
- Area Partnership Lead Contact
David Hughes
Proposed by Tam Coyle
Seconded by Gordon Millar
Substitute Representative remains Gary Atkinson
Tam, Gary and Scott will continue to serve as representatives on The Joint Action Group (JAG) of Ward 10 Community Councils.
ST said he had attended meetings of the Community Councils’ Development Session (CCDS) and found them useful.
- Note continuation of the Scheme for the Establishment of Community Councils.
This was noted.
Tam thanked officers of Glasgow City Council’s Community Councils’ section for providing an abridged version (reduced from 69 to 15 pages) which will be placed on the MCTCC Website.
- Appointment of an Independent Examiner of accounts for the next year
Gordon said this would again be Iain McGuire CA (retired)
The Treasurer added that he had gone through relevant Glasgow City Council (GCC) schedules for Community Councils and would submit the accounts to GCC after ensuring they conformed to good practice in line with the City Council’s requirements.
- Appointment of associate members.
The following were confirmed:
Peter Hayman
Ross Naismith
- Review the Inventory and Additional Resources
Gordon pointed out that some of then Community Council’s assets no longer have significant value because of depreciation but had to be recorded if they were still being used.
- Next Annual General Meeting
The Chair announced this will take place on Tuesday 28 October 2025, and closed the meeting.
(ST) to report to GCC:
- The date you held your AGM in October 2024
- Approved minutes of your last Annual General Meeting (AGM) in October 2023
- Approved Treasurer’s submission of Independently Examined Statement of Accounts from 1stSeptember 2023 to 31st August 2024
- Confirmation of membership of the Community Council, including all Office Bearers
Meeting Minutes, 26 November 2024
Confidential
Meeting of Merchant City and Trongate Community Council held over Zoom video on 26 November 2024
Attended by:
Community Councillors Tam Coyle (Chair), Gary Atkinson, Alice Cowan, David Cowan, Peter Hayman, David Hughes, Niall McColl, Colin McKay, Gordon Millar, Scott Thornton, Ros Wardley-Atkinson
Associate Community Councillor Ross Naismith
Ward Councillor Angus Millar
GA, CD, MD, TD, RE, GF, AM, EM, GMcI, PP, JR
Apologies - Baillie Christy Mearns. Councillor Eva Bolander, Councillor Philip Braat, Alasdair McDougall (MSP Kaukab Stewart’s office)
- MINUTES OF PUBLIC MEETING HELD ON 24 SEPTEMBER (The meeting on 26 October had to be abandoned because of security issues at Glasgow City Chambers)
These had been posted on the Website. Adoption proposed by Neill McColl and seconded by David Cowan. Carried.
- POLICE ISSUES
Tam said it was unfortunate that new beat officer Nathan Baxter had been unable to attend because Police Scotland cannot use Zoom or Teams for video meetings..
He told the meeting Miller Street was still being clogged with cars double parked on double yellow lines/pavements 7 nights a week.
Peter Hayman asked about pedestrianisation of Miller Street. There was nowhere for cars to go as it’s a dead end so why were they there? Tam asked where legal parking was available for those 30 or so cars?
Councillor Millar said he had been discussing the issue with the team re-developing George Square. Full pedestrianisation had not been discussed but he would be progressing public realm improvements.
JR said she had seen young adults crossing the road very slowly and holding up traffic outside Hootenanny near the St Enoch Centre, resulting in a back-up along Howard Street. Could police not monitor that area? Tam said he would raise this with PC Baxter. ACTION: TAM
Scott asked if there was any update from Glasgow City Council on buskers and if there had been confiscation of equipment because of contravention of the Buskers’ Code. Tam to raise with police. ACTION: Tam
Scott reminded the meeting that the Chair and Vice-Chairs meet Police at Inspector level quarterly and residents should contact them if they wished any particular issue raised. ACTION: All
- PRESENTATION ON RE-DEVELOPMENT OF GEORGE SQUARE AND AVENUES PROJECTS - by Cieran Buchanan, Principal Officer, Avenues Project, Glasgow City Council.
City Deal-funded (£115m): Sauchiehall Street pilot (Delivered 2018-19) Sauchiehall Street Precinct, Cambridge Street, Holland Street & Pitt Street, Argyle Street West, North Hanover Street and Kyle Street, George Square and surrounding Avenues, Argyle Street East, Clyde Street and Broomielaw, High Street (Glasgow Cross to Rottenrow)
Sustrans-funded (£21m): South Portland Street, Duke Street and John Knox Street, Cowcaddens Road and Dobbie’s Loan
Argyle Street West (Kingston Bridge to Hielanman’s Umbrella) - Due for completion October 2025, complexities due to low level rail line running the length of Argyle Street.
N Hanover Street/Kyle Street - Construction starting Spring 2025 for 18 months. Key link from city centre to new Sighthill development.
Stockwell Street - Contractor selection underway. Construction starts Spring 2025 for 15 months. Key link from city centre to South City Cycle Way.
South Portland Street etc - Construction starts early 2025, finished by Spring 2026. Key connections to areas on city centre periphery.
Argyle Street East (Union Street to Glasgow Cross) - Detailed design stage underway, construction to start end-2025 and completion by end 2027. Connects to Argyle Street West Avenue, providing a continuous East-West link.
Clyde Street/Broomielaw - Public consultation undertaken,. Construction to start early 2026, complete by early 2028. Key East-West link between Glasgow Green and West End while also connecting to South City Way. Clyde Street section well advanced.
High Street (Trongate to Rottenrow) - Early concept design underway. Funding still to be finalised. Public consultation took place in September.
Scott asked about the derelict land on the West of the High Street near George Street. Cieran said this is owned by Scottish Enterprise but GCC is hoping to use it as a construction centre for the contractor.
Councillor Millar said the site was originally intended to be Strathclyde University’s Technical Innovation Centre 2 but this would now be in the former Student Union building in John Street.
Peter Hayman said that as a keen cyclist he was pleased about the development of cycle lanes but what about monitoring of use? Cieran said Sustrans was investigating behaviour change. Investment had to be justified and Glasgow City Council was aware of this. Avenues’ connectivity would increase usage of cycle lanes.
In answer to a question from Colin McKay Cieran said the proposal for Argyle Street East included de-pedestrianisation of the precinct which could be hostile after dark.
George Square and Surrounding Avenues - Proposals involve 3 contracts - Main public realm (out to tender), hoarding contract for screening around the Square, and removal and conservation of statues.
Public realm - First stage includes St Vincent Street and West George Street, starting in April and completion August 2026.
Project coverage is ‘building to building,’ trees supplemented by rain gardens, ceremonial area retained, two horse statues retained on site but others removed for checks. Inclusion of cycle lanes.
An events space will include specialised lighting available year-round with possibilities for projection on surrounding buildings such as City Chambers.
Responding to questions on the Zoom Chat facility, read out by Niall McColl, Cieran said the hoardings around the Square would include summaries of the project’s benefits and promotion of events such as the Merchant City Festival.
Was there still be a water feature? In principle yes but there are significant difficulties. Costs mean this might not be possible.
There was no provision for public toilets in and around George Square.
Any provision for more CCTV? Webcam will be turned off for the duration of the construction but there would be a photo time lapse of the scheme.
Tam asked about statues which might not be retained. Why should Prince Albert be represented in view of his minimal connections with Glasgow? Cieran said this was not within his team’s remit.
David Hughes said the re-introduction of trees was positive. We were continually being told that planting trees in the city centre was problematic yet Ceiran’s schematic indicated this was not the case. Cieran agreed the number of trees in the plans depicted might be lower. Problems included getting the correct subsoil to help the trees survive.
- WARD COUNCILLORS’ REPORTS
(Councillors Bolander and Braat were unable to join the meeting because of technical difficulties)
Concerning trees Councillor Millar said there were various challenges concerning underground utilities. This was why Glasgow City Council was focusing on large scale planters. He was constantly asking contractors to come up with more cost-effective solutions.
Contributions from developers would be used more pro-actively to remedy public realm defects and improve the image of the city centre.
Another walkabout in the MCTCC area should be arranged for January.
Ross Naismith said there was not a single tree in Glassford Street. MCTCC should have an in-person discussion with Ward Councillors to get more trees planted.
Peter asked it the spare plinth planned for George Square could be used for a rotating artwork.
- LICENSING
Gary said he would be attending the Licensing Forum in the following week.
- PLANNING
Ross said that following the AGM held earlier that night he would be asking GCC Planning Department to send applications to him rather than Peter.
Niall said there was now a full planning application from the AXM night club in Glassford Street to GCC for a Pride Mural with comments due by the end of November. Tam said he had sent 7 emails to the owner without reply.
Scott asked Councillor Millar how a planning application could be judged when there was no information about what the very large mural would say. The application had to go before Council earlier than normal because it would contain advertising. Tam said he would ask GCC Planning. ACTION: Tam
Scott asked about the status of the derelict building site at the corner of Dixon and Clyde Streets. The developer had gone into administration. It had been an eyesore for many months. Councillor Millar said he would be discussing this with GCC’s Head of Planning. ACTION: Councillor Millar
- FUNDING FROM AREA PARTNERSHIP
David Hughes said the next meeting would be on 5 December. MCTCC had put forward 73 suggestions for donations from the £387k neighbourhood infrastructure fund.
He mentioned that Scott had circulated a note to Community Councillors about Local Place Plans (LPPs) which he believed was possibly the most important issue MCTCC should be tackling. This gives Community Councils the opportunity to effect change concerning student accommodation, trees and other issues concerning GCC’s City Development Plan 2.
- TRON THEATRE
Scott quoted an email to him from the Theatre Director who said she felt the Trongate area was the forgotten part of Merchant City. It was ravaged with drugs and graffiti.
- WEBSITE AND COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT
Niall said the new Website’s design was more or less complete. This and other community engagement initiatives would be progressed in the New Year.
- FRIENDS OF THE RAMSHORN GRAVEYARD
David Hughes said the next meeting would be on 11 December. A meeting had been held with Impact Arts for developing a Heritage Trail.
- LITTER PICK
David Hughes said we should hold the next one in February. ACTION: David Hughes
- TREASURER’S REPORT
Gordon Millar said the current bank balance was £6,364.24 after payments to ‘Friends of the Ramshorn Graveyard and for litter pick equipment. Cheque signatories had finally been sorted out.
- PUBLIC TOILETS
Scott reported on the meeting of the Community Councils’ Development Session he and Tam attended the previous Saturday which included a presentation by the MD of the British Toilet Association (BTA).
He noted there are no public toilets in the MCTCC area other than in retail premises. Tam said there was one in St Vincent Street/Buchanan Street,
GCC is holding a public consultation on the need for public toilets in the city.
Scott said the absence of public toilets was a serious gap in Glasgow’s attempts to attract more tourists. MCTCC would be responding to the public consultation. ACTION: Scott
The BTA MD had told Scott afterwards he felt a specialist contractor should handle public loos other than Glasgow City Council. Payments in future would be by debit or credit card. Even small payments had been found to substantially deter abuse and mis-use.
ANY OTHER BUSINESS
Peter said we should be recruiting more Community Councillors.
Tam said if any local resident attended 3 public meetings they would be welcome to join as an Associate or participate on an ad hoc basis.
Scott said this would be Peter’s last public meeting as a Community Councillor and he deserved a massive vote of thanks. Peter responded that it had been a pleasure to have helped make local residents’ voices heard.
Details of the next public meeting (in January) will be announced later.
Meeting Minutes, 24 September 2024
These draft minutes will be presented to our meeting on 29 October for ratification
Attended by:
– Community Councillors Tam Coyle (Chair), Gary Atkinson, Alice Cowan, David Cowan, David Hughes, Niall McColl, Gordon Millar, Scott Thornton, Ros Wardley-Smith
– Ward Councillors Angus Millar, Philip Braat, Baillie Christy Mearns,
– Police Constables Beth Cameron and David Colligan
– Media: Gary Fanning (Splash), Nicole Mitchell (Evening Times)
– Lisa Scott (Glasgow City Council), Fiona Stewart (Hawkins/Brown architects), Barbara Vecchione (New Practice Architects)
– NB, TD, DF, BL, KL, EM, AM, TMcK, KM, SM, PP, JR, CS
Apologies: Councillor Eva Bolander, Community Councillors Peter Hayman, Colin McKay and Associate Community Councillor Ross Naismith, PC Sean McFadden, GW
Minutes of Meeting on 27 August
Adoption proposed by Scott, seconded by Gordon. Approved.
Police Issues
PC Cameron reported on PC McFadden’s behalf that according to indicative figures between 27 August and 24 September there had been 193 offences in the MCTCC area of which 79 had been detected. These included assaults, bail breaches, retail theft, possession of controlled substances and threatening/abusive behaviour.
PC Steve Clarke has been moved to another beat in the city centre.
Although there were anecdotal suggestions of improvements in anti-social behaviour and drug misuse in the Ramshorn graveyard police continued to make regular checks there. Councillor Braat said he continued to receive reports of anti-social behaviour there as well as in George Street and Argyle Street.
Another 7 e-bikes had been sized for illegal modifications to make them go faster, making a total of 22 such seizures since March.
Riders had been charged with road traffic offences and could pay a significant amount to get the bike back in the condition it was found, Police could not confiscate the bike because it was their property.
JR said any cycling on pavements was illegal and should be enforced. Signage should be put up. PC Cameron said police could use other legislation to prosecute such as careless riding.
Councillor Millar said problems elsewhere in the city centre were being tackled by making certain sections cycle only and not shared with pedestrians.
Scott raised the issue of buskers, specifically the ‘Cat Man’ outside the St Enoch Centre. He had been giving a police warning but continued to ignore the busking code. Police had never confiscated any busker’s equipment. When was Glasgow City Council (GCC) going to take effective action to enforce its busking code? Signage said volume should be ‘reasonable’ but this was a very subjective term.
Gary noted the busking code said ‘music should not be heard over 30 metres away.’
Councillor Millar said GCC was trying to work with police but they couldn’t be there every time. He did not believe GCC had the power to enforce a legal volume level. Councillor Braat said buskers could often be heard 200 or 300 yards away.
CS asked why busking wasn’t only allowed in certain locations and why the use of amplifiers could not be banned. Councillor Millar said any such ban would require national legislation.
Custom House Quay Avenues Projects
A presentation was given by Lisa Scott – Principal Officer, Glasgow City Council, Fiona Stewart – Associate, Hawkins\Brown and Barbara Vecchione – Senior Designer and Architect, New Practice
An updated Proposal of Application Notice has been submitted for land and quay walls at Custom House Quay/Clyde Street. This relates to public realm and amenity enhancements, replacement and alterations to embankment walls and commercial works, and includes creation of a ‘River Park’. See https://www.meetourwaterfront.co.uk/
They explained this is part of the City Deal programme and arose primarily from the need to strengthen the quay wall which is nearing the end of its useful life. Several major projects were due to take place in the area, e.g. St Enoch Square re-development, and this was part of a larger Masterplan to make better use of the waterfront and improve access to it.
There would be a main gathering space, civic space, creative space and green space. The existing amphitheatre would be demolished.
It includes Carlton Place (outside the MCTCC area) where the emphasis would be more on a natural garden riverbank setting.
The developers are hosting two public events on 9th October at The Banqueting Hall, Glasgow City Chambers (11-2 pm and 5-8 pm). Local residents are also invited to a focussed workshop session which will give them the opportunity to discuss their thoughts and ideas with the design team. This will be on 8th October from 6-8 pm at 231 George Street.
Gordon asked why the South Portland Suspension Bridge did not seem to be included in the plan. The developers intended to tackle both sides of the river but nothing on the bridge which connected them? Lisa said there was nothing structurally wrong with it. Scott said a continuing problem could be graffiti which regularly covered every part of the bridge no matter how often GCC staff cleaned it.
Ward Councillors Reports
South Portland Suspension Bridge
Councillor Millar said the main lighting on the west side was operational but the East side had a fault and this required specialist equipment to fix. Spare parts were difficult to obtain and expensive.
Walkabout
Councillor Millar and Councillor Braat had taken part in a walkabout around the MCTCC area with Gordon. Problems had been noted and would be followed up. ACTION: Councillor Millar/Gordon
Councillor Braat said the King Street car park development would be mixed use. A public consultation was due on Wednesday 25 September.
ACTION: Tam, Gary and Ross will attend and report back
Tam reminded the meeting that MCTCC had been campaigning for years to have Merchant City’s first GP surgery. Developers should help pay for this. Scott said no developer behind student accommodation had offered to provide any substantial funding for local amenities and the Glasgow Health and Social Care Partnership had informed the Community Council there was no funding for a surgery in the foreseeable future.
Baillie Mearns said she had been informed that AXM in Glassford Street had permission from owners of the wall on which it planned to erect a mural to mark Pride Week 2025. Tam said he had been unable to contact AXM but would continue his efforts. ACTION: Tam
Gary said there was no information about what would be on the mural which would include advertising.
On ‘Trees for Streets’ Baillie Mearns said the sponsorship scheme did not apply to the city centre.
Scott asked whether money from Low Emission Zone fines was to be spent on planting more trees. Councillor Millar said £500,000 would be set aside, parts of which would be put towards the ’Trees for Streets’ programme and greening the city centre including installation of a score of large scale planters which would avoid the problems of public realm design and need to avoid underground utilities.
David Hughes said money from developers should be ring fenced for that particular part of the city. Councillor Millar said early identification of specific funding projects would be helpful.
Scott thanked Councillors Braat and Millar for taking part in the walkabout and thanked Gordon for leading MCTCC’s part in it. He also thanked David Fox who had taken over management of the latest litter pick, in which Ward Councillors had also taken part. This yielded 20 bags of rubbish collected by 17 people, using MCTCC’s own equipment.
Licensing
Application from Escape Room, St Enoch Square. Objections to be raised by 26 September.
Christmas Lights switch-on, George Square, Sunday 17 November. No objection.
GCC’s Licensing Committee is holding a hearing on licence applications by Dreamhouse 2000 Ltd tomorrow for short term lets at 120 Ingram Street. In February Gary/Ros lodged an objection on the basis of suspected ‘party flats’ and Scott did the same on MCTCC’s behalf.
ACTION: Gary attended. Approval was granted.
Planning
Purpose Built Student Accommodation (PBSA) including 137-151 Trongate and King Street car park re-development
Scot said MCTCC was fairly happy with the architecture of the above application and that the development was flexible to take account of future needs. It was the first time in many years a developer was trying to do something with the building and therefore was to be welcomed.
He added that the latest report on PBSAs, co-authored by Glasgow University, effectively rubbished a report by estate agent Savills which claimed a far higher shortfall. Why were so many PBSA applications being lodged and receiving approval?
Gary provided recent information from a publication co-authored by Glasgow University:
https://housingevidence.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/09/160924-Student-Housing-v3-.pdf
The key numbers outlined are:
Table 1
2022/23 – Student Accommodation need and demand estimates – Shortfall – 6093
Table 2
2022/23 – PBSA development and pipeline – 28 Schemes with planning permission with 7057 bedspaces, and 4846 bedspaces due to be operational within next 2 years
Area Partnership
(The forum in which representatives of the 7 Community Councils in Ward 10 meet senior Glasgow City Council officials)
David Hughes said there would be verbal report on PBSAs at a meeting on 26 September by the head of Glasgow City Council’s Neighbourhood, Regeneration and Sustainable Directorate, plus an update on busking.
There remained £370,000 in the Area Infrastructure Fund to be spent. The next meeting of the Area Partnership would be on 5 December. At our October MCTCC meeting we should have specific ideas on how that money could be spent.
These might include green spaces, leisure and play, street furniture/lighting and CCTV, potholes remediation, road safety and signage, clearing graffiti and Buddleia bushes. Ross, Ros, Alice and Niall had already put forward useful ideas. Suggestions should be given to David. ACTION: ALL/David Hughes
He had issues about the accuracy of Area Partnership minutes as reported by GCC. Community Councils’ anger about graffiti had not been mentioned. Instead, the only point mentioned was GCC’s emphasis on ‘legal’ graffiti walls. The AP is a conduit for Community Councils to express their views. Councillor Millar said no City Council meeting had verbatim minutes.
BL said more CCTV could deter graffiti. Tam said a cost of £17,000 per camera had been quoted.
George Square Re-development
Gary confirmed there would be a presentation at our October meeting from GCC project lead. ACTION: Gary
Website and Community Engagement
Niall said there should be an outline of the new Website soon. MCTCC is adding Threads to its Social Media outlets.
The Community Council’s two notice boards need cleaned up.
Meeting with new MP John Grady
Gary and Tam met him on 18 September. His Senior Parliamentary Assistant Ben McKee has been invited to attend future monthly MCTCC meetings. Dedicated meetings will be arranged with the MP, as with our MSP. Mr Grady will opt in to receive meeting minutes.
ACTION: Gary to follow up with Ben to provide photo and bio for Website and arrange next quarterly meeting.
Treasurer’s Report
Gordon reported a balance of £7,299.24 after payment of various invoices. A further £1,599 was due for the balance of Website costs.
Scott said a film company due to work in and around Parnie/King Streets next month has been asked for a contribution to our Community Grant Scheme.
Baillie Mearns said matched funding might be available from GCC for any project. ACTION: Possibility to be discussed at next Mid-Monthly Meeting.
Public Toilets Consultation
Scott explained GCC was asking for comments on its public consultation. Perhaps any Tourist Tax (Visitor Levy) could go towards providing these? There are none in Merchant City. ACTION: Scott
Arrangements for October Main Meeting (includes AGM)
All active Community Councils in Glasgow are due to hold their Annual General Meeting (AGM) in October.
Nominations for office bearers are welcome.
Any Other Business
Tam said MCTCC had received no notification of road closures for the 6 October Great Scottish Run.
ACTION: Niall to share information on Website.
Gary said re-location of Abbey Chemist had been discussed at a meeting convened by The Social Hub, Glasgow Health and Social Care Partnership, and the Chemist.
ACTION: A follow up-meeting, again to be driven by The Social Hub, will be held following next month’s opening of the Safe Drug Consumption Unit in Hunter Street.
BL asked about the future of the area around the Social Hub. Gary said there were no plans for any specific green space. There is outline planning consent for three further buildings on the vacant site. Gary has received confirmation that the pavement on Candleriggs will be reinstated this month and solid hoarding installed to secure the vacant site.
ACTION: MCTCC to remain in contact with DRUM Developments.
David asked if MCTCC meetings could be moved to another venue such as the Social Hub. Tam said he would be reluctant to move the venue from City Chambers. MCTCC remained grateful to all four Ward Councillors for enabling this.
Next Main Meeting (Includes AGM)
Tuesday 29 October, 6.30 pm – City Chambers.
Meeting Minutes, 25 February 2025
DRAFT MINUTES
Meeting of Merchant City and Trongate Community Council (MCTCC)
Glasgow City Chambers on 25th February 2025
Community Cllrs: Tam Coyle (Chair), David Hughes, Niall McColl, David Cowan, Gordon Millar, Gary Atkinson and Ros Wardley-Atkinson.
Assoc. Comm. Cllr Ross Naismith.
Elected Cllrs: Cllr Angus Millar, also Alisdair McDougal from Kaukab Stewart MSP Office.
Police: PC Martin and PC Ishfaq.
Ex-Officio: Gary Fanning (The Splash).
Residents: DF, RA, MG, KG, RE, GMcI and TMcK.
By video link: Cllr Eva Bolander, Alice Cowan, EM, GW and AM
Apologies: Scott Thornton, Colin McKay, Peter Hayman, Depute Lord Provost Christy Mearns and Cllr Philip Braat.
MINUTES OF 28TH JANUARY MEETING
The previous minutes are available on the MCTCC website.
Adoption of minutes: Proposed by David Cowan, Seconded by Gary Atkinson. Carried.
POLICE REPORT
PC Martin read out from a Police Report for the MCTCC area prepared by PC Baxter.
From the 1st to the 25th of February a total of 77 crimes were reported of which 39 had been detected. This included theft (especially from retail premises), possession of controlled substances, road traffic offences and disorder offences. A warrant search at a property was carried out and report submitted to the Procurator Fiscal (PF).
PC Ishfaq reported they have been attending to local issues such as ebike riders. Since the end of December 2024, they have seized 24 illegal e-bikes and reported 102 offences to the PF. They continue to be proactive in monitoring their impact on the streets. An unannounced day of action is planned in the near future.
A resident complained about ebikes not using cycle lanes when they are available and riding on the pavement instead, very near to pedestrians. It was discussed how ebikes are not allowed on payments.
The police have been monitoring Ramshorn Graveyard and the New and Old Wynd lanes.
Gary Atkinson has had reports of people gaining access to private doorways to take drugs, sleep or cause damage.
ELECTED MEMBERS’ REPORTS
Councillor Millar
Councillor Millar attended the MCTCC litter picking event on Saturday 22nd of February.
He also attended the recent walkabout survey with community councillors and Louise Stewart, the Community Neighbourhood Liaison Officer. She will follow up on the issues discussed such as drainage problems and poor or damaged signage on High Street.
Cllr Millar attended the Custom House Quay consultation where he saw several CC members. He has contacted the developers at Dixon St and Broomielaw area regarding the long term lack of progress on the site.
Ross Naismith commented on the excess street furniture on Glassford St; from to Wilson St to Ingram St, where there are 11 poles on the pavement. Cllr Millar will enquire as to the feasibility of removing any redundant poles or having the information otherwise displayed, on a wall for example.
GW noted how binmen are coming to empty the bins at the Santa Lucia restaurant, near to Albion St and Ingram St, at 5am which wakes everyone up. Tam enquired about the upcoming band marches, he understands that they will not be allowed to go to George Square, to lay a wreath for example. Tam commented the streetlights at the bottom of Millar St have not been working for five months, residents have reported this many times.
Ebikes
Cllr Millar confirmed that ebike cyclists, under the Highway Code, are not allowed on pavements unless there are signs to say otherwise. It is unacceptable to ride in a way that endangers anyone. The police do stop ebikes if they have been recklessly towards a member of the public. Tam noted that MCTCC recommended that ebikes riders wear an identifiable number tabards, or such like, to be made more traceable.
RA enquired about what the situation on the pedestrian precincts such as on Argyle St or Buchanan St? Cllr Millar believed they should dismount, depending on how crowded the street is. Ros Wardley Atkinson enquired if there could be any signage for ebike riders to slow down in pedestrian areas to act as a deterrent. Cllr Millar would take this onboard for consideration.
George Square Redevelopment
Cllr Millar recently attended an exhibition on the redevelopment of George Square.
A George Square Redevelopment Communication Plan has been setup. Information notice boards will soon be erected in the square to improve public awareness of the project phases.
The information on the boards have received positive feedback. However, Ross Naismith considers they are hard to read due to the being too dark. Cllr Millar has heard that the surface on which the text is printed makes it difficult to read
GCC have laid sand on the former grass areas until upcoming events and construction is complete. This will save money from having to re-turf them several times over
Gary Atkinson suggested that perhaps a QR code might be put on the George Square noticeboards so people can learn more or enquire further, Cllr Millar agreed. Kieran Buchanan, who is part of The Avenues project, will be giving a presentation at the March MCTCC meeting.
Councillor Eva Bolander
Councillor Eva Bolander reported the GCC annual budget has been approved. This includes added revenue for the Cleansing Services and the Deep clean Team. She has a meeting next week with The High Street Reference Group which MCTCC has contributed to with neighbouring CCs. She reminded everyone that the benches are being relocated from George Square during the redevelopment works. They may be taken back once the project is complete.
PLANNING ISSUES
Ross Naismith spoke to the King St car park developers recently who are looking to renew their planning application by the start of the next quarter.
He attended the Custom House Quay and Calton Place consultations and put forward our endorsement, subject to conditions. They will submit a PPP, which means ‘planning permission in principle’. Both projects will have a review for further input.
He reminded the meeting of the consultation on the new hotel development in Maxwell Street on will take place in Granite House on Thursday 27th February.
He will attend an ‘in person hearing’ on the proposal at Old Wynd at Osborne St, this a proposal for a 15 storey building. MCTCC put an objection for this development in early 2024. The architect of Heritage Society of Scotland also put an objection. He is minded to submit a second objection due the height and the saturation of student accommodation in Glasgow.
Ross Naismith suggested that if student accommodation is to be built, it should be designed to be flexible enough such that it can be reconfigured to accommodate regular apartments in the future. Objections about the concentration have not been as successful as those complaining about the lack of design merit.
David Hughes added that Sarah Shaw, head of planning, gave a presentation to the Area Partnership (AP) last December on student housing. A holistic view about the number of developments was not considered, but only the individual application basis, however this is now changing.
Tam and Gary met the Drum developers the week previous regarding the three plots adjacent to Candleriggs. Drum developments have a PPP to delay starting building from 2025 to 2028.
The Clutha Vaults have put a planning application for a LED light presentation board around the roof of the bar at the end of the Broomielaw. It is 20m long, 5m high and will include flashing LED lights. MCTCC is minded to object.
Ross has approached the local Councillors about improvement plans for High Street.
It is anticipated that the existing plans will be reviewed. Cllr Millar has expressed a view, along with Bailie Christy Mearns, of increased ‘greening’ from George St down to Trongate.
The final decision by the Scottish Government Reporter has approved the Artisan Developers residential development application at Ingram St. This is where the Merchant City Park (MCP) group fought to community ownership to install a park instead. The main condition attributed by the Reporter relates to noise proofing from the Fruitmarket Concert Hall to the new residential building.
Local Place Plan (LPP)
David Hughes, as well as several other community councillors, have been attending the online training courses to develop a LPP.
NW AREA PARTNERSHIP
David Hughes attended the last Area Partnership meeting on the 13th of February. Police Inspector Jonny Watters gave a report on how they are implementing the new Busking Action Plan. Officers will patrol the city centre fortnightly accompanied by GCC Community Enforcement Officers discuss this with street performers.
The Scottish Fire and Rescue Service (SFRS) are currently holding a public consultation on its strategy for 2025-2028. It closes on Wednesday 2nd of April. It can be accessed here:
https://www.firescotland.gov.uk/get-involved/consultations/sfrs-strategy-2025-2028/
David Hughes has submitted 5 bids for the National Infrastructure Fund by the 21st of February. This included the planting of 74 trees in the Merchant City; a new children’s play area on Albion St / Ingram St; pedestrianisation of Candleriggs; refurbishment of the Tron Steeple and the replacement of 2 dead trees on Ingram St. There are 7 CCs eligible to apply with their list of 5 bids. The bids will be voted for approval at the next AP meeting on the 27th of March.
Ross Naismith will have an informal meeting with David Hughes and Cllr Millar to discuss how these initiatives could still be taken forward if not successful with AP funding. MCTCC have applied to the LEZ fund for tree planting.
Two seating benches have been installed on Ingram St, which came from George Square. There are more benches available, people should contact Cllr Eva Bolander if they have suggestions of suitable locations. It was suggested the area outside the Old Sherriff Court, however this may be subject to planning permission. Gary Atkinson added the Drum developers who will contact Cllr Bolander direct for bench seating.
Student housing will be discussed at the next AP meeting and may issue a statement regarding this which could feed into the next City Development Plan.
LICENCING
There is an application for a market on Osbourne St from 25th April to 25th May and will have 25 stalls. This is at the back of Argyle St Rail Station, near to the taxi rank. The last day to object is the 18th of April.
LOCAL ISSUES
Busking
The police will carry out a day of action to ensure the recently published code of conduct is being adhered to.
Pavement, and Double, Parking
Tam reported there is a lot of double parking on Millar Street. He enquired who is responsible for monitoring parking after 8pm at night when the majority of infringements take place. Cllr Millar will feedback to Tam.
Public Toilet Consultation
No update this month.
Litter Pick
David Hughes was pleased the Saturday 22nd February event was a success. There were 22 volunteers including 8 community councilors, 9 new attendees and 4 people from The Garment Factory. They collected 32 bags of litter. A follow up email was received from a group across the river who will carry out a litter pick there, DH shall loan the equipment.
Gordon Millar observed a noticeable difference in the cleanliness of our area now. There is a large amount of litter on the River Clyde riverbank at Calton Place. There is an opportunity to link up with other groups for future clean-ups.
David Hughes asked Cllr Millar what provisions are in place for the litter closer to the river, over the metal fence. GCC hire a specialist contractor to do this. This issue was noted during the walkabout survey. Louise Stewart has undertaken to see if this can be arranged.
FRIENDS OF THE RAMSHORN GRAVEYARD (FORG)
David Hughes reported the next quarterly meeting is the 12th of March. He attended a first aid course in St Andrews, he has arranged public liability insurance for FORG. A suitable uniform for tour guide duties will be purchased. They will start to advertise in March with a view to starting tours in June.
WEBSITE AND COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT
Niall McColl reported the final draft of the updated website will be finished this week.
The community survey will take place in April.
The two MCTCC noticeboards have been deteriorated due to vandalism over the last few years despite being cleaned. An email will be sent to community councillors to consider what is the best option going forward.
TREASURER’S REPORT
Gordon Millar (Treasurer) reported MCTCC have £,6,725.51 in the bank. Tam invited funding applications, for use within our area, to be submitted for consideration.
Niall McColl reported that House Productions will be filming in Wilson St and will make a donation to affected residents and MCTCC.
Emails from GCC with funding opportunities now only be received by Gordon Millar.
AOCB
Scottish Premier League Celebration Plan
Regarding the end of the football season celebrations for the winners of Scottish Premier League, Tam, Scott Thornton and Alistair McDougall (from Kaukab Stewart MSP office) met with John Grady MP two weeks ago.
Tam suggested the use of Celtic Park, the Emirates Arena and/or Glasgow Green to distribute crowds and reduce pressure on the local area. A meeting is scheduled for March 28th at Hampden Park with multiple agencies to discuss the situation. Ross Naismith welcomed this initiative and believed it could make the celebrations at least more manageable.
Gary Atkinson attended the Glasgow Life Forum last week for the City Centre Strategy 2030. He noted after the presentation there was no reference the much-publicised Tourism Levy or Business Improvement Districts (BIDs). Cllr Millar believed once both had been confirmed they would be incorporated in the end document.
David Cowan noted a chess club now runs in the Namaste Indian restaurant in St Enochs Center on Wednesday evenings between 6-9pm.
NEXT MEETING: Tuesday 25th March, 6.30-8.30 pm in City Chambers
Upcoming Road Closures
Road Closures
This page will inform you of various types of road closures taking place in Glasgow.
Roads affectedand dates and times of restriction applying to all vehicles, with the exception of an emergency service vehicle carrying out an emergency response or vehicles given permission from Glasgow City Council filming and events section.
From 16:00hrs to 20:00hrs on the 9 February 2025
Prohibition of vehicle movements
- Stobcross Road between Congress Road and the loop road also known as Stobcross Road
*access to the A814 will remain open at all times.
Reason for Restrictions
To facilitate a temporary restriction for the safety of road users.
“vehicle” unless the context otherwise requires, means a vehicle of any description and includes a machine or implement of any kind drawn or propelled along roads whether or not by mechanical power;
“emergency service vehicle” means a vehicle being used by the Police, Fire or Ambulance Services and includes blood transfer vehicles operated by the NHS.
“Prohibition to vehicle movements” applying to all directions unless otherwise stated.
Roads affected and dates and times of restriction applying to all vehicles, except for an emergency service vehicle carrying out an emergency response or vehicles given permission from Glasgow City Council filming and events section.
From 06:00hrs on the 15 March 2025 until 22:00hrs on the 17 March 2025
Prohibition of waiting, loading and unloading
- St Vincent Lane between Hope Street and Wellington Street
From 11:00hrs on the 15 March 2025 until 23:00hrs on the 17 March 2025
Prohibition of vehicle movements
- St Vincent Lane between Hope Street and Wellington Street
Reason for Restrictions
To facilitate a temporary restriction to enable members of the public to watch this event and being satisfied that it is not reasonably practicable for the event to be held otherwise than on a road to allow St Patrick’s Day Celebrations to take place.
“vehicle” unless the context otherwise requires, means a vehicle of any description and includes a machine or implement of any kind drawn or propelled along roads whether or not by mechanical power;
“emergency service vehicle” means a vehicle being used by the Police, Fire or Ambulance Services and includes blood transfer vehicles operated by the NHS.
“Prohibition to vehicle movements” applying to all directions unless otherwise stated.
Meeting Minutes, 27 August 2024
These draft minutes will be presented at our meeting on 24th September for approval
Meeting of Merchant City and Trongate Community Council held on 27 August 2024 in City Chambers, from 6.30 pm
Attended by: Tam Coyle (Chair), Gary Atkinson, David Hughes, Niall McColl, Gordon Millar, Ross Naismith, Scott Thornton, Rosalind Wardley-Smith, Ward Councillors Baillie Christy Mearns and Angus Millar, PC Sean McFadden, RA, CD, ND, MD, DF, AM, AMcD, AMcD, HMcD, TMcK, KL, MR, NM, PP.
By Zoom video: Alice Cowan, David Cowan, AC, SL, EM, JR
Apologies: Councillor Eva Bolander, Peter Hayman, Colin McKay, PS
MINUTES OF 30 JULY MEETING
Proposed by Tam Coyle, seconded by Niall McColl. Approved.
POLICE ISSUES
PC McFadden (SMcF) reported that in the period 30 July to 27 Aug in the MCTCC area (for police purposes this excludes the St Enoch Centre) there were a total of 160 reported crimes, 52 of which were detected - i.e. someone was apprehended or the perpetrator known. These figures are indicative. Crimes included assault, bail offences and retail thefts.
Tam asked about a recent instance of a vehicle being driven the wrong way way up Candleriggs and noted that the southern part of that street is signposted pedestrian-only. He quoted residents as saying there were not enough police officers visible on the street but noted that often they were in plain clothes and not in uniform.
SMcF said the Ramshorn graveyard had become a hot spot for drugs misuse and was receiving a lot of police attention. Arrests had been made, partly after alerts from the public. Police were also liaising with Glasgow City Council about clearing up needles. David Hughes thanked police for their interventions.
Police had a contingency plan to cope with a possible demonstration in George Square on 7 September by supporters and opponents of the Far Right.
Police had taken action against illegal e-bikes which were sometimes being ridden at excessive speeds.
In response to a point by a resident about slow police response times Tam said the issue was on the agenda for MCTCC officials’ regular meetings with the city centre Police Inspector.
DISTURBANCES BY FOOTBALL FANS
Scott reported that earlier today he and Gary met MSP Kaukab Stewart (who kindly hosted the meeting) and representatives of Celtic and Rangers football clubs to discuss ways of avoiding repetitions of the anti-social behaviour experienced in May 2023 and May 2024.
WARD COUNCILLORS’ REPORTS
Baillie Mearns, catching up on issues following her maternity leave, said she was pleased with various aspects of the refreshed pending planning application for development of the King Street car park.
She was also pleased budget funding had been approved for the ‘Trees for Streets’ project. The Council is now looking at possible sites.
Baillie Mearns expressed thanks to MCTCC for its donation to Impact Arts which recently celebrated its 30th birthday.
Councillor Millar said there would be another community walkabout with Ward Councillors on 17 September (1-2.30 pm). Scott to advise details and meeting point. ACTION: Scott
The ‘direction of travel’ for development of the waterfront between Custom Quay and Stockwell Street was on a smaller scale with greater emphasis on stabilising the quay wall and improving the public realm.
There would be a consultation on Tuesday 3 September (12–3 pm) on the High Street Avenues project. Venue: 231 George Street.
DF asked about the lack of trees around new housing developments.
He went on to complain about the standard of street cleansing and lack of Glasgow City Council (GCC) resources. Was GCC relying overly on volunteers doing litter picks? Money was being spent on ‘pointless’ projects such as painting bins (often covered with graffiti) rather than on such a basic requirement.
RN said he, Gary and Scott had a constructive meeting with developers of the King Street car park on site yesterday and were assured their comments were being taken on board. Their attitude on a connection between Trongate and The Briggait mirrored ours. The developers also agreed planning would be flexible to meet changing demands of the marketplace.
Scott said this showed the benefits of early consultation with residents. Thanks in large measure to Ross’ experience and expertise we had been able to perhaps influence the plans.
Noting that the plan included more student accommodation, he repeated MCTCC’s plea to GCC to get a grip on the issue. The Community Council had complained time after time about over-concentration of Purpose Built Student Accommodation yet applications were continuing to be approved. The inclusion of ‘Co-Living’ in the King Street plan was student accommodation by another name.
Ross said he was underwhelmed by the first two presentations he had attended on the Avenues project. The Custom Quay-Stockwell project did not address residential requirements.
In response to a complaint from RA about fouling by pigeons and seagulls, Councillor Millar said signage could be improved to ask the public not to feed birds. Commercial waste was a particular problem. GCC had set times for this and perhaps enforcement on businesses which did not adhere to this should be stepped up.
ND said a smoking area behind Pipeworks “gentlemen’s sauna’ in Metropole Lane was not only causing a fire risk because it is in an enclosed space but also creating noise into the wee small hours right outside her flat. ACTION: Angus
Another resident complained about regular parking on double yellow lines by contractors working on the new Afro-Caribbean supermarket being built on the former Corrigans fishmongers’ site on Howard Street.
Angus said he would look into a problem reported by BR about water ingress into flats in Montrose Street. ACTION: Angus
KL brought up the issue of a taxi rank set up without due notice outside the GPO Building in Ingram Street. This had been raised with Councillor Braat two meetings ago. Scott said he had received no reply from GCC to his query asking when the re-siting of the rank from George Square had been advised to local residents. Tam will discuss with Councillor Braat. ACTION: Tam
HOMELESS PROJECT SCOTLAND
Earlier in the meeting TD had raised problems arising from Homeless Project Scotland (HPS).
Tam summarised that this opened in Glassford Street last December as a homeless shelter and was serving food.
GCC had ordered the owner and occupier to apply for planning permission (change of use from offices) by 31 March but no such application had been lodged.
Scott said meetings had been held with senior GCC officers including the Head of Planning in early June and a letter sent to the Chief Executive, Council Leader and Scottish Government. Meetings had been held with MSP Kaukab Stewart, all to no avail.
However, he had been assured at a meeting with a senior GCC officer last week that a Planning Enforcement Notice would be served to the owner and occupier at the end of August.
It was disappointing that no reply had been received from Food Standards Scotland six weeks after MCTCC asked it to advise whether HPS had the relevant licence.
Gary added that lack of action by Glasgow City Council was continuing to deprive local residents of the opportunity to comment on an application.
Tam said it was the most frustrating case he had encountered in his 18 years on the Community Council. Sleeping accommodation was provided but there was only one fire escape.
Councillor Millar said he shared Tam’s frustration. Intensive efforts had been made to find an alternative site.
Gordon said it was clear the site had not been zoned for that activity so why was it being asked to apply for planning consent for a purpose to which it was not entitled? What was the point of zoning in the first place?
LICENSING
An application had been lodged for an ‘Escape Room’ in the St Enoch Centre. Tam said MCTCC had no objection.
Gary explained that permission for bars or restaurants to provide pavement tables was covered by their overall licence based on the space allowed. They did not need a separate licence.
PLANNING
Tam said Ross was now assisting Peter Hayman with planning issues.
Ross had responded to GCC’s consultation on tall buildings on a personal basis but the Community Council now had to respond on its own behalf. All comments should be passed to the Secretary by 13 September, after which he will draft a response in conjunction with the Chair and co-Vice Chairs.
Scott said he and Gary met with senior GCC planners to discuss the George Square development and Avenues project between Custom Quay and Stockwell Street. We were keen to avoid problems encountered with the Sauchiehall Street works and requested residents’ representation, as an observer, on a monitoring body for George Square redevelopment.
We were offered a 1-1 update each month and a presentation at our October meeting. Scott will arrange this. ACTION: Scott
Scott added that a presentation on the Custom Quay-Stockwell Street project may be delivered to an MCTCC meeting early in the New Year.
George St/High Street derelict site - Scott has asked Ward Councillors to advise the status of this eyesore. Tam said the developer had run out of money. Angus is following up. ACTION: Angus
Second stage of Candleriggs Square - Tam, Gary and Scott have met the developer to discuss this, with building due to start early next year. Tam said designs for a new mural would be presented to the Community Council when available.
RA asked about the Pride pavement in Wilson Street. Tam said the first MCTCC knew about it was when it was finished. it was uneven and created a trip hazard.
David Hughes said Local Development Plans fed into city development plans so it was important for MCTCC to comment on LDPs on issues such as student accommodation.
Pride Mural on AXM building, Glassford Street - Tam said the telephone number he’d been given does not accept messages. It was noted this 12 x 7 metres mural will dominate a large part of conservation area and will include advertising. ACTION: Tam
TD said AXM did not own the building.
LITTER PICK
David Hughes said this would take place on Saturday 21 September, from 10.30-1pm, meeting at the Ramshorn graveyard gate. MCTCC has received grant funding from Glasgow City Council for equipment which will be provided to volunteers. ACTION: David Hughes
GRANT GIVING SCHEME
Niall said there was currently £6,500 in the fund and summarised the criteria. Further applications are welcome. Applicants do not have to be a registered charity. ACTION: All
FRIENDS OF THE RAMSHORN GRAVEYARD
Free public tours will be organised next year, tour guides trained and story boards created. The next meeting will be held from 6.30-8.30 pm on 4 September with a specialist speaker. More members are welcome.
WEBSITE AND COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT
Niall said an outline of MCTCC’s new Website should be ready by mid-September.
He will draft a short questionnaire to be completed by all Community Councillors as a mini-biog.ACTION: Niall
TREASURER’S REPORT
Gordon reported a bank balance £6,573 once outstanding cheques had been cleared. A GCC grant of £700 is expected around November. MCTCC’s accounting year end is end-August.
David Hughes said £367,000 remained in the Area Partnership fund. MCTCC should submit applications for suitable projects, otherwise other Community Councils would spend it. The Merchant City Handbook includes many good ideas and could be used as a source document. Tam said one project could be installation of a CCTV camera around Parnie Street. ACTION: All
PUBLIC TOILETS
GCC is developing a strategy and actions around public toilets and inviting representations. There are no public toilets in Merchant City/Trongate or on Glasgow Green following closure of the People’s Palace. Scott is liaising with GCC on our response. All comments are welcome. ACTION: Scott/ALL
NEXT PUBLIC MEETING
Tuesday 24 September, 6.30 pm, City Chambers
Meeting Minutes, 30 July 2024
Meeting of Merchant City and Trongate Community Council held in City Chambers on 30 July 2024.
Attended by: Scott Thornton (Chair), Gary Atkinson, Rosalind Wardley-Smith, Niall McColl, Peter Hayman, David Hughes, Gordon Millar; Glasgow Merchant City Festival representatives; Police Constable Sean McFadden (SMcF); EM, RM, KL, TD, SM, CS, BF, CD, RF, PS, TMcK, RN
MSP Kaukab Stewart : Glasgow City Council - Lise Fisher and David MacDonald, Rowan Evenstar - Blythswood & Broomhill CC
By Zoom video - Alice Cowan, David Cowan, MS, SL, AC, EM
Apologies: Tam Coyle, Peter Hayman, Ward Councillors Philip Braat and Eva Bolander
MINUTES OF 25 JUNE MEETING
Adoption proposed by Gordon Millar, seconded by Gary Atkinson. Approved.
POLICE ISSUES
PC McFadden (SMcF) reported indicative crime statistics as follows for the period 25 June to 25 July in the MCTCC area: 203 offences reported of which 107 were detected. These included assaults on police officers, street drinking, possession of controlled substances, threatening and abusive behaviour, and retail theft. Main involvement related to licensed premises.
Priority locations have been a focus of attention, working from local feedback.
A number of major events, including The Open Golf, TRNSMT, General Election, Pride and marching season have taken up more resources than usual.
Day of action on Illegal e- bikes - 4 July- 11 bikes confiscated that were not road- legal. Further enforcement action is expected as well as continuing engagement.
MSP KS asked about police action in the Trongate area. SMcF reported there were regular high visibility patrols, supplemented by additional resources when available. In response to a further query on whether anti-social activity was growing, SMcF anecdotally viewed more activity, particularly when the weather is better.
There were several concerns raised around drug dealing & needles in the Ramshorn graveyard and associated shoplifting from the local Sainsbury’s.
Concerns were raised on the perceived increase of tents appearing in different parts of the city centre. Police and GCC were aware and work with third sector services to support those individuals to limit the number of tents.
The area around the Portland Street suspension bridge was raised by RN given the, at times, intimidating atmosphere. RW-S raised the change in demographics in the MCTCC area and associated impacts and asked if any data was available?
Issues were discussed around accessing flats’ communal areas in Ingram street being used for drug dealing/taking and rough sleeping. Police will engage with factors involved to ensure all security measures are being implemented.
GA emphasised that reporting of incidents is helpful to police as it provides data.
Presentation from Glasgow City Council on Safe Needle Bins trial
Lise Fisher (Neighbourhood Liaison Manager Ward 10) presented feedback from the trial (May 2023 for 6 months):
Accessible Sharps disposal bin located in New Wynd Lane, Trongate (No. 1 location historically for needles) to address the concerns of local people given the number of items discarded.
Trial collected around 5,000 items in the period including needles and associated paraphernalia. This was during a period where there was an increase in drug usage in the area.
The bin is still in use and being monitored and utilised.
In future other areas such as car parks may also have “sharps” bins where regular use is reported. These areas are monitored to see if an additional bin would be effective.
Reporting of sharps items helps GCC assess resource priorities. Best way is via the MyGlasgow app which has a map locator for reporting and identifies clusters of discarded needles. The reporting options will be added to the MCTCC website ACTION: Niall
There was a query about whether personal data from the MyGlasgow App would be used (not believed to be the case).
DM noted that there were approximately 8,500 regular users in Glasgow and 400-500 in the city centre. There is a voluntary system of care and treatment to help control addiction, though it is felt Glasgow draws users from around the country.
The Hunter Street health facility is now close to completion, with staff recruited. This will provide more support for the more serious drugs. GCC/HSCP are awaiting a Letter of Comfort from the Lord Advocate. Recently there has been an application for a “drug checking” facility at Hunter street to increase intelligence on street drug chemistry.
MSP KS indicated that Christina McKelvie (Scottish Minister for Drugs and Alcohol) is actively involved in these issues.
GA highlighted the potential risks of some new student planning applications close to McDonalds in Argyle Street that may add to the existing volume of users.
Lise Fisher updated the meeting on the Street Art on Custom Quay - a “Legal Wall” six month pilot which will allow officially sanctioned art in the area. The main issue is that there are now less resources allocated to graffiti cleaning by GCC. DH flagged that some of the artists involved in the Custom Quay project are also covering private buildings.
MSP’s Report - Kaukab Stewart
Issues raised with our MSP include cladding remediation, which has been a major point. KS clarified that wooden decking is included within the Single Building Assessment (SBA) programme.
The Merchant City car park planning application decision was discussed.
Homeless Project Scotland (HPS) - GCC Planning have confirmed no application has been received, in addition to issues raised on safeguarding of occupants and fire safety (no breaches reported). A Planning Enforcement notice will now be issued by GCC (date awaited for issue). KS will follow up. ACTION: KS
Elaine Bennet of Spires Apartments said the building was sold to Quintessential for retail/offices. There had been lots of complaints from Spires’ guests about anti-social behaviour from soup kitchen users and Spires had lost business. She quoted HPS as saying it had agreed a 15 year lease to move the soup kitchen to the ground floor and the accomodation to the basement. This would double kitchen capacity.
Ros mentioned that the management of Social Hub had raised concerns about Brunswick Lane and thereabouts being used for drugs and other antisocial behaviour
Kaukab said the student accommodation issue attracted lobbying from all sites. There needed to be a sustainable solution that met the requirements of all parties.
MCTCC is progressing a request to put a student accommodation moratorium in place for the Merchant City and will discuss with our Ward Councillors at the next meeting.
GM asked about the Single Building Assessment. Had the associated building regulations from the Scottish Government been finalised for cladding remediation buildings? ACTION: KS
The Pride rainbow pavement at the Merchant City Festival - feedback on several issues in terms of cost, safety for mobility users and if there was any local public consultation. ACTION: Lise Fisher
Other Matters
Public Consultation on high rise buildings - encourage all to take part and make your views known. MCTCC to discuss if they should submit a formal response - ACTION Scott
George Square - request for local input into the redevelopment submitted. Awaiting a response. ACTION: Scott
TREASURER’S REPORT
Gordon reported a bank balance of £9,722.13 at 30 July.
Discretionary grant funding has been applied for which will followed up by the Treasurer. ACTION: Gordon to discuss with Gerald Tonner @ GCC.
The Annual Administration Fee has also to be confirmed: ACTION: Gordon
WARD COUNCILLORS’ REPORTS
No Councillors were in attendance.
In Brief
Website Update - Being re-designed as a ‘Go To’ Hub for local information.
Ramshorn graveyard - “Puddle” being investigated - GCC has been informed.
College of Printing and Building (Met Tower - 'People Make Glasgow’ building): RN subsequently reported this is up for sale.
Boundary changes impact on MCTCC area query - Now Glasgow East rather than Glasgow Central.
Planning - Candleriggs development - EM asked if there was any progress as he had noted water pressure issues in his property. ACTION: Gary
NEXT MEETING
Tuesday 27 August, 6.30 pm in City Chambers
Meeting Minutes, 25 June 2024
Attended by: Scott Thornton(Chair), David Cowan, Gary Atkinson, Rosalind Wardley-Smith, Niall McColl, Peter Hayman, David Hughes, Gordon Millar ; Lorenzo Mele & Bernadette Fryars - Glasgow Merchant City Festival; Police Constable Sean McFadden; EM, RM, KL, TD, SM, CS, BF, CD, RF, PS, TMcK, RN;
By Zoom video - Alice Cowan.
Apologies: Tam Coyle, Ward Councillors Philip Braat and Eva Bolander;
MINUTES OF 28 MAY MEETING
Adopted proposed by David Cowan, seconded by Gordon Millar. Approved.
POLICE ISSUES
PC McFadden (SMcF) reported indicative crime statistics as follows for the period 28 May to 25 June in the MCTCC area: 131 offences reported of which 60 were detected. These included assaults on police officers, bail breaches, threatening and abusive behaviour, and retail theft. Main involvement relating to Licenced premises.
Taken a number of crime prevention surveys to help mitigate retail crimes
Following a report from a member of the public, police had executed a Sheriff’s warrant in Bell Street, but no crime was detected.
Police were now operating “proportionate response to crime” pactice, based on the THRIVE model of assessment, looking to free up police where there is “no viable lines of enquiry” , Only applies to “low harm & low risk” crimes, eg theft, vandalism & failure to stop (North division found this was c 3.4% of reported crime when they started earlier this year).
Police worked with Wheatley Group to improve the timely repair process for damaged doors, that were associated with anti social behaviour. Expected to result in faster repairs for these buildings.
The Tron theatre area was discussed, where there had been a significant impact from the recent Football celebrations in Merchant City and regular drug dealing activities. The Police suggested the latter be reported to help focus the appropriate response. Regular Police patrols are planned.
There was no information on E-Bikes, but the Police were planning “days of action”.
It was noted that there would be a GCC presentation on the Needle Bin project at the July mtg.
Busking - More planned engagement from the Police, no reported enforcement
Graffiti / Vandalism update - Scott attended a meeting with Police Scotland (Paul and Angela Stavely). Main points were encourage reporting of the incidents (E mail / online / Crimestoppers) and the Council have powers to require Private property Owners to clean up damage.
Scott highlighted that GCC have designated part of Custom House Quay area for “Street Art”
MERCHANT CITY FESTIVAL (19-21 July 2024)
Lorenzo Mele, Artistic Director & Bernadette Fryers , Project Manager, Merchant City Festival at Glasgow Life gave a presentation and took questions.
Summary of the programming:
Main Sponsers - Merchant Square, Candleriggs Accomodation & The Social hub
Focus around Merchant Square for Music every day and using SURGE outdoor performances during the 3 days
Friday - Music programming (Celtic Connections organising) / Carnival feel /. Also a Civic reception taking place Friday afternoon.
Saturday - Pride & Family friendly programming
Sunday - 50’s theme / Rockabilly / / Ramshorn graveyard / New Candlerigg Square / Family friendly.
Boardwalk for a Science Museum event & Quiet space. The Old Fruitmarket Friday night for “Hip replacement” night club (7pm -midnight)
Big Angie (comedy / drag show) for 2 nights
Bernadette highlighted the operational matters - Festival set up & Road closures - Resident and Businesses notified mid June - from Fri 6am to Sun Midnight.Operational hours during the day are 12 noon to 6.00pm
There will be a walkround by the project team of Businesses to discuss deliveries / access etc on 26 June.
There were questions around Parking and access and it was suggested that the letter should be added to the MCTCC website and any issues Residents should call the helpline number on the letter.
WARD COUNCILLORS’ REPORTS
No Councillors’ were in attendance at the meeting.
Points raised in absentia:
Update on the Celtic Fans issues from 18 May & feedback from Council liaison with Celtic FC
Higher than expected Orange Marches - 100 over the summer around Glasgow , with 50 on 1 day.
Walkabout with Councillors - Actions list update . Next walkabout invite should include Councillor Braat and and focus on the Southern part of the district next time, specifically on the riverside.
Pavement parking in Candleriggs issue - get bollards similar to Miller street?
Litter on the River banks of the Clyde (North and South banks) - potential joint litter pick with Calton CC?
Can Councillors’ bring more disused properties back into Residential accommodation, as per the policy raised in the City Centre Strategy presentation.
STREET CLOSURES - Noted
PLANNING
Scott shared the success of planning being granted to Damasquino for their expanding successful restaurant in Saltmarket.
Homeless Project Scotland (HPS)
Letter has been sent to the Chief Executive of GCC , regarding the lack of enforcement of the planning breach related to HPS.
There have also been representations made to the Scottish Government regarding GCC not operating statutory planning legislation
New applications for PBSAs
The latest such application is for Granite House, 31-33 Stockwell street.
This is a Change of Use application from Office to Student Accommodation
Scott noted this led through Old Wynd to two other buildings which had received planning permission for PBSAs, in effect creating a mini student campus. In addition there has been an old Hotel planning permission that is also now being revised for Student accommodation.
There are currently 1365 rooms in planning in the MCTCC area and this will take the number to well in excess of 1,500 in a relatively small area, in addition to major Student developments situated close to the MCTCC area e.g. College lands.
Since MCTCC policy is to oppose further applications for PBSA he will submit a formal objection. ACTION: Peter
George Square redevelopment -
Can we obtain details of the phasing of closures, work and reopening over the project period. Action -Scott to review.
RN suggested it would be helpful if a member of the MCTCC attended the Project meetings, to feedback on phasing and delivery on a timely manner, similar to the issues in Sauchiehall street. ACTION :
Merchant City Park
No Progress reported.
Public Consultation on high rise Buildings - Obtain details
GPO Building - Taxi rank relocation - Scott has asked GCC about whether this can be amended and Cllr Braat is discussing with GCC staff.
LICENSING
Carry forward to next meeting.
Scott raised with GCC some Holiday Letting applications in Ingram street in Feb 2024. This was acknowledged in June 24.
TREASURER’S REPORT
Gordon reported a bank balance of £9,750 at 25 June 24
David Hughes said he had made an application to GCC for £520 for litter pickers. This is for a maximum of £400 Grant (may be the Cash received - to check) Gordon
Discretionary Grant funding has been applied for which will followed up by the Treasurer . Action Gordon to discuss with Gerald Tonner @ GCC.
The Annual Administration Fee has also to be confirmed - Action Gordon
£400 has been received , but this needs to be confirmed what this covers. Action Gordon
GRANT GIVING SCHEME
Impact Arts Press release sent out (with QR codes, link to the MCTCC website).
FRIENDS OF THE RAMSHORN GRAVEYARD
Meeting to be held in City Chambers tomorrow. David Hughes said an aim was to start public tours in 2025.
SCOTTISH FIRE AND RESCUE SERVICE PUBLIC CONSULTATION
WEBSITE/COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT
Communication strategy - Sub group agreed to propose that we should spend up to £3,000 on the Website and c £55 per month on maintenance. This will support our communication with the wider community and improve engagement.
David Hughes proposed a full launch with flyers to local businesses, University and apartments to help drive traffic to the new website.
The spend is aimed at updating the web site (from 2019), provide more dynamic presentation, making it more usable to communicate whats on, news and history in the MCTCC area.
There is also the possibility of further enhancement to the website to involve local businesses that support the site and engage with these businesses on future MCTCC communications.
Proposed by David Hughes and seconded by Christian S. No objections. Agreed to progress.
AOCB
Items for the meeting with Kaukab - Councils ignoring National Planning guidelines, Continual roadworks on the M8, The council being more proactive in communicating strategy.
NEXT MEETING: Tuesday 30 July, 6.30 pm in City Chambers
Meeting Minutes, 28 May 2024
These draft minutes will be reviewed at our next meeting on 25th June.
Attended by: Tam Coyle (Chair), David Cowan, Peter Hayman, David Hughes, Gordon Millar, Scott Thornton; Ward Councillors Philip Braat and Angus Millar; Ian Elder, Glasgow City Council; Police Constables Stephen Clarke and Sean McFadden; TD, DF, NF, TMcK, RN; By Zoom video - Alice Cowan, AC, CD, SL, EM, SM, CS.
Apologies: Gary Atkinson, Niall McColl, Colin McKay, Rosalind Wardley-Smith; Ward Councillor Eva Bolander; Eileen Mills
MINUTES OF 30 APRIL MEETING
Adopted proposed by Tam Coyle, seconded by Gordon Millar. Approved.
POLICE ISSUES
PC McFadden (SMcF) reported indicative crime statistics as follows for the period 30 April to 28 May in the MCTCC area: 144 offences reported of which 84 were detected. These included assaults on police officers, bail breaches, threatening and abusive behaviour, and retail theft.
Police had seized six e-bikes in the city centre illegally modified to remove the speed limiter. More such seizures were expected. A total of 15 bikes were involved throughout Glasgow. Scott reported this would be on the agenda when he, Tam and Gary meet MSP Kaukab Stewart in early July.
Following a tip-off from a member of the public, police had executed a Sheriff’s warrant following seizure of illegal substances on King Street.
A police officer had been appointed to specifically target vandalism and graffiti in the city centre as this is a rising issue. Scott said he was due to meet her in the coming weeks.
There was lengthy discussion about the serious disturbances and vandalism following Celtic FC fans’ celebration of their team’s Premiership title win on 18 May, when 25,000 massed at and around Glasgow Cross.
Many attendees spoke of their anger at the damage, violence and widespread litter caused. Tam noted that Rangers fans had rampaged through the city centre, targeting Celtic fans, running past police vans.
Glasgow Council staff were commended on having cleared the area in time for the Cancer Research Race for Life the following morning.
Sympathy was expressed for police who had been left to keep some sort of order in the mayhem, albeit incurring large overtime costs paid for by the public. Tam said he, Scott and Gary had discussed the pending problems with Inspector Johnny Watters well before 18 May.
PC McFadden said police had tried to provide a ‘proportionate’ response with the main aim of keeping people safe.
Scott asked what contacts GCC had held with Celtic or Rangers FCs.
Councillor Millar said Glasgow City Council had an ‘ongoing dialogue and engagement’ with Celtic FC although neither Celtic nor Rangers had made any comment about that event or disruption in and around George Square when Rangers won this season’s League Cup or their ‘Ultras’ fans rampaging through parts of Merchant City on 18 May. He encouraged local communities to continue to agitate about the problem.
Councillor Braat said the behaviour was unacceptable. All parties had to shoulder part of the responsibility.
David Hughes said the clubs were opting out of their responsibilities. They should be made to pay for the damage and other costs incurred.
Tam said the situation was the same as the previous year when Celtic had also won the league. Lessons had not been learned.
Councillor Braat said there was a ‘spiral’ of such activity and the problem was likely to occur again next year.
Scott noted that MCTCC had issued a joint press statement with Calton Community Council, condemning the fans’ behaviour and stressing the effects on residents and businesses, and would be taking the matter further.
He quoted local residents saying police had been slow to turn up, only appearing in significant numbers after a large crowd had already gathered. The incidents had been a stain on Glasgow’s reputation; Glasgow was trying to attract tourists; this was having the opposite effect.
EM quoted a fellow resident in his block that she had been frightened that flares set off during the disturbances on 18 May could have set light to cladding.
SL asked for more CCTV cameras to be installed in the inner city. PC McFadden said public space was allocated by GCC. Councillor Millar said it cost £30,00 to install a single camera with an annual running cost of £10,000.
On another matter, the Director of the Tron Theatre had reported via email that drug peddling and use had become worse around Chisholm Street. Users were sharing entry codes for various flats. PC McFadden said he was aware of one suspected premises.
CITY CENTRE STRATEGY
Ian Elder, Project Manager, City Centre Regeneration at Glasgow City Council, gave a presentation and took questions.
The Strategy brings together Glasgow City Council (GCC) and Scottish Government plans including National Planning Framework 4 = A ‘Plan of Plans’.
Almost 50% of Scotland’s population live in or within an hour of Glasgow.
There are three pillars:
‘Magnetic Experience’ - More compelling reasons to visit, shop and enjoy the city centre. Development of the riverfront. Complete work on the quay. Recognise new patterns such as working from home. Glasgow has a fantastic cultural life which GCC needs to support.
‘Front door to innovation’ - Digital, health technology, climate science and creative industries which converge with arts, engineering and business. Glasgow manufactures more satellites than any other city in the world outside North America.
‘A place to live’ - Responsible to planet and people-inclusive. Moves to Net Zero. Double city centre population by 2035. Climate resilience, development the evening and night time economy including better transport links. ‘Connecting green places.’ Mixed localities had been shown to be more resilient post-Covid, as in New York.
Empty properties are being targeted for re-purposing. GCC is looking to use its existing powers more assertively and requesting additional powers from the Scottish Government. It is investigating more innovative ways to heat homes and office buildings.
AC said a large number of buildings in Glasgow and 20% of those in Scotland including historic buildings were off the national gas grid. How could they connect to the network? Councillor Millar replied that GCC’s strategy depended on national policy for connecting with low carbon energy sources.
Ian said GCC wanted to support communities with small scale interventions.
Tam said if it wanted to ‘green Merchant City’ why had it approved construction of 109 flats on the NCP car park in Ingram Street, a site which should become Merchant City Park (MCP)?
Almost every construction project discussed at MCTCC meetings over the past two years had been about student accommodation. MCTCC wanted more social housing.
RN asked what was happening with MCP. Scott explained that the Scottish Government Reporter gave her report to Ministers back in January and they were still considering it.
Peter said the strategy did not contain adequate provision for facilities for the elderly.
A total of 18 priority actions included the Avenues project, which would include the ‘Highlandman’s Umbrella,’ also covers George Square which Councillor Braat said should be completed in April 2027, and the stretch from Central Station along Clyde Street to the Trongate.
RN criticised that particular part of the Avenues project saying there were too many barriers to access the River Clyde and different teams were handling different segments and different remits. The strategy was not holistic. He had lodged an objection to the proposal following the recent public consultation.
Councillor Millar replied that these were covered by different funding sources.
A resident said there was a pressing need for a primary school in the MCTCC area. Councillor Millar said such funding depended on the Scottish Government.
David Hughes said more ‘swing parks’ and green spaces were needed. The situation resembled Easterhouse in the 1960s. The Plan had an absence of local leisure amenities and was flawed.
RN countered that Glasgow Green was a wonderful such amenity. Expenditure on play parks in Merchant City should not be at the expense of good quality architectural projects.
Another resident said there were many attic-type residential spaces which could be re-purposed.
Ian’s presentation slides will be sent to MCTCC and made available for all to view on the Website. ACTION: Tam
RN asked about the future of the College of Building and Printing site. Tam explained this was outside MCTCC’s area but he would liaise with Townhead Community Council. ACTION: Tam
PURPOSE-BUILT STUDENT ACCOMMODATION (PBSA)
Attendees again complained about the continuing surge in applications for Purpose Built Student Accommodation (PBSA).
Councillor Millar said GCC did not have the power to mandate certain property types. The City Council wanted a mix of residential developments. Social housing would be part of the St Enoch Centre re-development.
David Hughes said GCC’s Planning Committee has the right to grant or refuse planning permission. Townhead Community Council and other CCs were ‘disgusted and appalled’ at the high number of applications there.
Answering questions on the City Centre Strategy, Ian Elder said developers were looking for a relatively high Return on Investment of 5-6% which explained their preference for PBSAs.
RN said students were a temporary population. An indigenous population was preferable.
A resident said Glasgow City Council was focussing too much on student accommodation. IE said although students came and went there would always be students in Glasgow.
WARD COUNCILLORS’ REPORTS
Councillor Millar said 3,100 parking tickets had been issued in the MCTCC area between January and April.
Scott asked if GCC was concerned at the snail’s pace progress of the Scottish Government’s Single Building Assessment Programme which is supposed to remediate dangerous cladding and timber decking to avoid another Grenfell-type disaster.
Set up in 2021, the programme had so far only completed 2 developments with work started on only 28. He had been informed that a large proportion of the buildings concerned were in Glasgow.
Councillor Braat said the problem was known at Lancefield Quay where it was causing owners problems concerning insurance and mortgaging as well as safety.
Re city centre busking Councillor Millar said GCC would publish a paper tomorrow and it would be discussed at the Council next week. Additional signage was planned to communicate the limitations. He will send the paper to MCTCC. ACTION: Councillor Millar
TD said the direction of traffic at the junction of George and Albion Streets should be changed because it was creating a hazard. This would be covered by Councillor Millar’s Walkabout with Community Councillors tomorrow.
BMcK complained about installation of air-conditioning on a building on Saltmarket which he said did not have planning permission.
NF said smells from polystyrene boxes left in pallets by a restaurant in King Street ‘resembled raw meat.’
PLANNING
Homeless Project Scotland
Councillors complained anew about the failure of Glasgow City Council officers to even respond to repeated enquiries from MCTCC about why no enforcement action had been taken on the required Change of Use application for the homeless shelter in Glassford Street. Community Councillors stressed the disturbance and annoyance to neighbouring businesses and residents including Spires Apartments and the House of Gods Hotel.
Scott quoted GCC’s policy on Planning Enforcement which the Council’s Website described as ‘high priority’ and underlined the need to ‘safeguard the amenities of neighbours.’
New applications for PBSAs
The latest such application is for 137-151 Trongate (near the British Heart Foundation charity shop).
This is for demolition of a category 'B' listed building at 137-143 Trongate and unlisted building at 145-149 Trongate and erection of a 9-storey short-stay serviced apartment building, including retention of category 'B' listed facade, ground floor retail unit and use of first and second floors of category 'B' listed building at 151 Trongate as serviced apartments
Scott noted this led through Old Wynd to two other buildings which had received planning permission for PBSAs, in effect creating a mini student campus.
Peter said the proposed tower was ‘not aesthetic.’ Since MCTCC policy is to oppose further applications for PBSA he will submit a formal objection. Closing date for objections is 7 June. ACTION: Peter
GP surgery
As part of its campaign to get the first GP surgery in Merchant City, MCTCC has submitted a Freedom of Information request to Greater Glasgow Health and Social Care Partnership about the number of local residents registered with practices elsewhere, and will follow this up. ACTION: Scott
LICENSING
Peter said six applications for Short Term Lets (STL) did not seem problematic.
Scott noted that an application for an STL did not have to be refused if the apartment concerned shared a common entry. This is only one of the factors which the Licensing Committee has to consider.
MERCHANT CITY FESTIVAL
To take place from 19-21 July.
TREASURER’S REPORT
Gordon reported a bank balance of £9,750.
David Hughes said he had made an application to GCC for £520 for litter pickers.
GRANT GIVING SCHEME
Scott is arranging a photoshoot for presentation of the approved £1,000 donation to Impact Arts.ACTION: Scott
Tam asked everyone for suggestions for other grants for local good causes. ACTION: ALL
FRIENDS OF THE RAMSHORN GRAVEYARD
Meeting to be held in City Chambers tomorrow. David Hughes said an aim was to start public tours in 2025.
SCOTTISH FIRE AND RESCUE SERVICE PUBLIC CONSULTATION
Gary and Gordon attending this event tomorrow.
WEBSITE/COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT
MCTCC sub-group meeting on 10 June to create an action plan. This will include a presentation on a revamped Website.
AOCB
RN said owners in the Italian Centre had been presented with extraordinary remediation costs as it was a listed building. He asked for ideas for heritage grants. ACTION: All
He asked about the derelict site bounded by George Street, High Street and College Street. Could the owner be asked to at least tidy it up? Peter suggested the site should be protected by GCC.ACTION: Peter/Ward Councillors
NEXT MEETING: Tuesday 25 June, 6.30 pm in City Chambers
NEXT MMM - Tuesday 11 June, 6 pm, iCafe







